Friday, March 14, 2025
No menu items!
HomeNatureShould the Stanford Prison Experiment be retracted more than fifty years on?

Should the Stanford Prison Experiment be retracted more than fifty years on?

Hello Nature readers, would you like to get this Briefing in your inbox free every day? Sign up here.

A close-up image of a piece of rock on Mars, in which the pattern resembles leopard spots

The black-ringed ‘leopard spots’ on a Martian rock might be evidence of chemical reactions that could have involved microorganisms. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS

Dark-rimmed ‘leopard spots’ in a rock studied by NASA’s Perseverance rover last year could be the remains of microbial activity on Mars. The rings aren’t a sure sign that microbes once thrived on the Red Planet; the only way to know for certain is to analyse a sample of the leopard-spotted rock here on Earth. Perseverance has a sample awaiting a ride off Mars for precisely that purpose. For now, the rings are being treated as ‘an intriguing signal’ of ancient Martian life, but far from a sure thing, said researchers at a conference yesterday.

Nature | 5 min read

Researchers have identified 64 genes that help to shape how quickly a person’s brain ages. The team analysed brain scans from nearly 40,000 people and calculated each person’s ‘brain age gap’ (BAG) — the difference between their predicted brain age and their chronological age. Using genetic data from just over 31,000 healthy participants from the cohort, the team homed in on 64 genes linked to BAGs, some with roles in blood clotting and cell death. They also pinpointed 13 potential drugs that have been explored in clinical trials that could be used to target these genes.

Nature | 4 min read

Reference: Science Advances paper

A genomic study of people who lived more than 6,000 years ago hints that ancient European hunter-gatherers might have voyaged across the Mediterranean to Africa. Using DNA from bones or teeth from nine individuals found at archaeological sites in the eastern Maghreb region — present-day Tunisia and northeastern Algeria — researchers found that Stone Age populations who lived there were descended, in part, from Europeans. At that time, there were more islands poking above the waves in the narrow strait between what’s now Sicily and Tunisia, which could have eased the journey for ancient voyagers in simple boats.

Nature | 4 min read

Reference: Nature paper

Researchers have forged relatively large sheets of metal that are just atoms thick. The team took inspiration from ancient copper forging techniques to squish molten droplets of metals such as bismuth, lead and tin into 2D sheets in a tiny sapphire anvil. This allowed them to study how the properties of super-thin sheets of the metals differ from 3D chunks of the same material. The team now have their sights on a new design that they hope will extend the technique to work with metals that have melting points above 500 ℃.

Nature | 5 min read

Reference: Nature paper

PUTTING THE SQUEEZE ON. Graphic shows a new method of making atoms-thick metal sheets.

Source: Adapted from Figure 1a of ref. 1.

Features & opinion

While researching the infamous Stanford Prison Experiment for a book, social scientist Thibault Le Texier was struck by how quickly it all falls apart under scrutiny. The ethics of the mock jail study — which described undergraduate volunteers descending into sadism and breakdown — are questionable at best. Lead researcher Philip Zimbardo might have pinched the design of the study from junior team members without crediting them, and the results were sent to the media immediately, with no peer review in sight until 1973 — two years after the experiment concluded. The myriad problems Le Texier highlights raise a question, writes sociologist Augustine Brannigan: should the study be retracted? It might not even be possible — the journal that eventually published the paper no longer exists. “If Le Texier’s findings are credible, arguably the best outcome we can expect is more responsible reporting in contemporary textbooks,” Brannigan writes.

Retraction Watch | 14 min read

“Elisabeth Vrba’s meticulous studies of fossil and living mammals challenged the conventional view of evolution” writes palaeontologist Niles Eldredge. Among the achievements of Vrba, who has died aged 82, was a solution to a problem that Darwin grappled with throughout his career: “how could the great diversity of species over vast stretches on continental areas have occurred in the absence of obvious barriers that would cause reproductive isolation?” Vrba’s answer was that cataclysmic environmental changes can fragment and isolate habitats, and cause waves of extinction and evolution.

Nature | 5 min read

Image of the week

Animated sequence from video of a robot arm picking up a small orange ball and placing it in a miniature basketball hoop.

A machine running the AI model Gemini Robotics places a basketball in a hoop.Credit: Google DeepMind

A team at Google DeepMind has put a version of its large-language model Gemini into a robot arm. With Gemini’s help, the arm can ‘slam dunk’ a miniature basketball through a desktop hoop — despite never having watched another robot do the action, says the firm. The hope is to create machines that are intuitive to operate and can tackle a range of physical tasks, without relying on human supervision or being preprogrammed. (Nature | 4 min read) (Google DeepMind)

QUOTE OF THE DAY

Mental-health advocate Lian Zeitz works with researchers to ensure that the experiences of people with mental-health conditions are at the centre of research practices. (Nature Reviews Psychology | 5 min read)

Today I’m trying harder to understand how dogs are feeling. You might think that interpreting a dog’s emotions from its body language is easy, but it turns out that we’re actually pretty bad at it. Researchers found that we tend to pay attention to the surroundings of our canine friends to glean context as to whether they’re excited, sad or scared, rather than looking at what they’re actually doing. Co-author Clive Wynne is taking the results to heart, using the findings to “guide [his dog’s] life toward greater happiness”, and so am I.

While I find a dog to emotionally connect with, why not send your feedback on this newsletter to [email protected]?

Thanks for reading,

Jacob Smith, associate editor, Nature Briefing

With contributions by Flora Graham

Want more? Sign up to our other free Nature Briefing newsletters:

Nature Briefing: Careers — insights, advice and award-winning journalism to help you optimize your working life

Nature Briefing: Microbiology — the most abundant living entities on our planet — microorganisms — and the role they play in health, the environment and food systems

Nature Briefing: Anthropocene — climate change, biodiversity, sustainability and geoengineering

Nature Briefing: AI & Robotics — 100% written by humans, of course

Nature Briefing: Cancer — a weekly newsletter written with cancer researchers in mind

Nature Briefing: Translational Research — covers biotechnology, drug discovery and pharma

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments